
I’ve lived with it for three weeks now and can finally say the new PJ Harvey album, White Chalk, is astonishing. The shift to writing on piano has subtly twisted the songs [ironically similar to the way Nick Cave got a new angle by moving from piano to guitar on the Grinderman album] leaving a lot more space for texture. Two/three minutes into To Talk To You there’s all kinds of strange static noises buzzing away deep in the mix.
Even when songs start off as “normal” PJ creations - The Piano’s “Hit her with a hammer. Teeth smashed in. Red tongues twisting. Look inside her skeleton” over a Rid Of Me style guitar throb - it doesn’t take long before the sound goes off into all kinds of new directions with harp and zither. Which makes the “Nobody’s listening” and “oh God, I miss you” refrains even more spine-chiling than they would have been over a straighter rock backing.
The much-hyped “amateur” keyboard playing is interesting [sounds rather like me finding a piano at three in the morning after copious amounts of vodka]. She’s using the piano in a very repetitive, percussion way with lots of repeated phrases and hammered on-the-beat notes. The effect is sometimes like that Richard James was aiming for on the slower more Satie-esque tracks on Aphex Twin’s Druqs. Also, it carves out routes back to Polly’s roots - other Too Pure artists like Pram and Moonshake.
The whole vaudevillian schtick with the hair and dresses made me think first of the new American folk revivalists. You can almost imagine her out in some backwoods in Louisiana jamming for four hours on a broken banjo. But the outfits are also peculiarly English, harking back to a kind of English rural 19th century naturalist art. Makes me think of Thomas Hardy. You can imagine Polly [even the name works] heading out on a moonlit night to take the short walk over the hill to relatives in the neighbouring village. It can only end in tragedy.
The title track, White Chalk, is the most explicitly “placed” with the line “white chalk sticking to my shoes” showing just how much she’s not only connected with her home landscape, but just how much that landscape has, literally, rubbed off on her. And it’s an old trick, of course, the idea of getting a sense of mortality by looking at landscape and geology. But it’s still spine-tingling when she says “I know, these chalk hills will rot my bones.” I know I will die. I know I will be buried here. Or, I know that if I stay here these chalks hills will rot me.
And on Silence. “All those places where I recall the memories that gripped me and pinned me down. I go to these places pretending to think. I can think of nothing … I freed myself from my family. I freed myself from work. I freed myself and remained alone.”
The final track, The Mountain, is one of the most astonishing. Beginning with a swirling piano figure that almost recalls Joanna Newsom, but she doesn’t give that piano any space or room to breathe. It just gets more and more dense and dark and murky. A feeling added to by an insistent scary bass line and a thrilling ending with Polly pushes her voice right to the top and turning the lines after “… since you betrayed me so” into almost a scream.
It will be interesting to see where she goes from here. Hopefully it won’t be a one-off meander into more experimental territory, but the start of an artist who has always been interesting [but on the fringes of my interest] really pushing to break free. If she’s going to walk down some dark paths then I’ll be sticking with her.